November 5, 2026
For twenty years, a small city-issued medallion on a Truman Annex door meant the unit could be rented by the week. By Feb. 1, 2026, owners had to return those medallions to the City of Key West Licensing Division. That deadline was set in a city letter dated Dec. 5, 2025, which told every affected owner that their transient licenses would be "placed into inactive status and void on Dec. 22, 2025," according to Keys Weekly.
Key West sorts rentals by length of stay. Under the city's licensing FAQ, stays of 28 days or less are transient and stays of at least 29 days are non-transient. Shorter stays need a transient license, and the city limits where those can exist. The FAQ lists HRCC-1, HRCC-3, HCT, HNC-1 and HNC-3 as the zoning districts that allow transient use. It also describes a cap on new licenses and says that converting a residential property to transient use can be difficult or "possibly impossible."
Truman Annex was different. It is the former Navy property that developer Pritam Singh bought at auction in 1986, according to the Truman Little White House. Its weekly rentals rested on a 2005 settlement that ended three lawsuits involving the city, the Truman Annex Master Property Owners Association and the Shipyard Condominium Association. That agreement created about 280 special licenses. Units could rent weekly for half the year and monthly for the other 26 weeks, and the deal had a firm sunset in December 2025, as the Key West Citizen reported.
Keys Weekly described weekly rentals as "significantly more lucrative" than the monthly rentals allowed at most Key West properties that lack "a pricey transient rental license." For two decades, a buyer in the Annex got that premium without having to buy a license separately. The premium came with a clock attached.
In the Foundry lawsuit, the city argued that owners claiming historic rental use had to apply for nonconforming status with records of rental activity before 1998, and the deadline was in August 2005, as the Key West Citizen summarized it.
That means rights can differ from one unit to the next even inside the Annex. Craig Tellerd, a Truman Annex owner, told the Key West Citizen that 12 properties there hold licenses that never expire. He described them as a continuing nonconforming use in the community. If that is accurate, two homes behind the same gate could carry very different income potential.
The roughly 280 expired licenses added nothing to the citywide supply of transient licenses, which remains capped. A September city letter, quoted by Keys Weekly, said all active Truman Annex transient licenses "will be automatically closed in the city's licensing system on Dec. 22, 2025." Keys Weekly explained that this meant they would not be circulated or made available for purchase by owners in other parts of town.
The city's transfer application, revised Sept. 28, 2026, calls for signatures from the owners of both the sending and receiving sites. It describes review by the Development Review Committee and the Planning Board, with city fees totaling $6,458.33. That figure covers processing only. The price of the license itself is set privately between the two owners.
The 2026 Florida Statutes, Section 509.032, bar local governments from prohibiting vacation rentals or regulating how long or how often they are rented. The statute exempts local laws adopted on or before June 1, 2011. The most recent major attempt to rewrite the state's vacation rental rules, SB 280, passed both chambers and was vetoed on June 27, 2024.
The Foundry Homeowners' Association, which represents 29 townhouses in one section of Truman Annex, sued the city to keep its licenses. Above the Fold reported that the 142-page complaint was filed Dec. 22, 2025, the day the licenses expired. The case was assigned to Judge Tim Koenig of the 16th Judicial Circuit on a streamlined track, and the complaint seeks damages over $100,000 along with declaratory or injunctive relief.
The owners point to Section 509.032 and to vested rights built up over years of renting. The city's response, filed Feb. 16, 2026, frames the case as a contract dispute. "This is not a new ordinance," the city argued, according to the Key West Citizen. "It is a contract that the Foundry voluntarily joined." When that paper covered the motion in February, no ruling had been scheduled.
Owners who hope for an extension rely on one clause in the settlement, which the Key West Citizen quoted:
"Registered Short Term Rental Units owned by Non-Party Owners may be used for Short Term Rentals for a period of 20 years, at the end of which Non-Party Owners will cease Short Term rentals, unless Short Term Rentals are otherwise permitted by law or agreement at that time."
Tellerd told the paper the words "or agreement at that time" were added so the parties could extend the deal if they all agreed. So far, the city has not agreed. Owners organized as the Truman Annex Residential Property Owners, or TARPO, offered $750,000 a year for 20 years, $15 million in total, to buy existing market-rate multifamily units. Those units would be deeded to the city as affordable rentals for Key West police and fire personnel in exchange for a 20-year renewal. The proposal did not make the November or December 2025 commission agenda.
Commissioner Donie Lee explained the city's reasoning to Keys Weekly. He said he had been advised that extending rights for Truman Annex would mean offering them to everyone who wants them, "a Pandora's box that I'm not willing to open."
This post is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Confirm the details of any specific property with a Florida real estate attorney and your tax advisor. Before writing an offer anywhere in Key West that assumes rental income, these are the questions worth settling:
Did the expired Truman Annex licenses become available to buy? No. The city closed them in its licensing system on Dec. 22, 2025, so they were not released for purchase elsewhere in town.
Does state vacation rental law override the sunset? That is the central question in the Foundry case. The owners rely on Section 509.032. The city argues that the statute applies to ordinances, not to a private settlement signed in 2005.
If you are weighing a Truman Annex home or any Old Town property where rental income is part of the plan, Bobby Coe can help. Schedule a private consultation.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.