November 12, 2026
On May 27, 2026, the Monroe County Planning Commission took up a request for three lots at 8 Parrot Lane on Geiger Key, just past Big Coppitt off U.S. 1. Planning Policy Advisor Barbara Powell explained the request. The lots, about 19,825 square feet in total, sat in the Sparsely Settled district, which requires 80 percent open space. The owner wanted Suburban Residential, which requires 50 percent. It was the fourth request like it in the area in the last several years, and county staff recommended approval.
Commissioner Scarpelli said the change looked like a way to add a pool. He also noted it would bring the existing house into compliance. Then James Brownlee, the ex-officio member who represents Naval Air Station Key West, formally objected for the Navy, according to the Planning Commission minutes. He said the property sits on the boundary of Accident Potential Zones 1 and 2 and inside Noise Zone 2, at 70 to 75 decibels. He called sustained noise at that level "fundamentally incompatible with further development." The item was postponed to June 24, 2027.
A neighbor asking for a little more room for a pool ran into a federal installation, and that tells you how land works around Boca Chica Field.
Monroe County's Comprehensive Plan includes a Military Installation Area of Impact, or MIAI, around NAS Key West. Its policies took effect on July 19, 2012. One policy addresses increases in density and intensity:
Any Future Land Use Map amendment that raises density or intensity must be sent to NAS Key West, and the commanding officer has 30 days to comment. If the Navy says the parcel is in a land use incompatibility zone, the Board of County Commissioners must adopt a finding on whether the restrictions apply. The plan also tells the county to encourage the Navy to buy such lands. In a noise zone, the Board makes its finding and public hearings are scheduled 90 days later. The Board can also make approval conditional on the owner waiving claims against the county, or indemnifying it, over current or future Navy operations.
State law reinforces this. Florida Statute §163.3175 requires local governments near military installations to send certain plan and regulation changes to the installation and to consider its comments. The full policy text is in the county's adopted Comprehensive Plan.
The Navy's current Air Installations Compatible Use Zones study, known as the AICUZ, is dated February 2018. It projects the 65 dB DNL noise contour across the southern half of Big Coppitt Key. DNL is a day-night average sound level. South of U.S. 1 on the island's eastern end, the noise comes mainly from Field Carrier Landing Practice and from fighter departures off Runway 08: FA-18E/F Super Hornets, F-5 Tigers and F-35C Lightning IIs. North of U.S. 1 on the southwestern side, it comes mainly from Runway 08 departures and Super Hornet break arrivals to Runway 22.
The noise zones translate into planning guidance like this:
| Navy noise zone | Day-night average | County MIAI table guidance for residential |
|---|---|---|
| Zone 1 | Below 65 dB DNL | Outside the bands the table addresses |
| Zone 2, lower band | 65 to 69 dB | Discouraged; if allowed, at least 25 dB outdoor-to-indoor noise reduction |
| Zone 2, upper band | 70 to 74 dB | Strongly discouraged; if allowed, at least 30 dB reduction |
| Zone 3 | 75 dB and above | Transient housing at 75 to 79 dB assigned 35 dB reduction |
The county table was written against the 2007 AICUZ, and the Navy redrew its contours in 2018. The table's guidance is framed as compatibility recommendations, so confirm a parcel's current designation with county planning staff.
Compare that table with the Navy's own FAQ. On the NAS Key West AICUZ page, the Navy says standard construction provides 15 to 25 dB of attenuation, depending on whether windows are open or closed. It lists sealing exterior openings, sound-insulating windows and doors, and added wall insulation as ways to get more.
The 2018 study is built on airfield operations data from 2013, forecasts roughly 52,000 annual operations and plans through calendar year 2028. The Navy says the AICUZ is reviewed periodically and can change with new aircraft or higher operations.
The map is drawn in contours, and they don't follow street lines. A 2025 case on Avenue A shows the difference a few blocks can make.
The parcel at 305 Avenue A is in the Johnsonville plat at the north end of Fourth Street, across from the Lower Keys Cemetery, around mile marker 10. Its owner asked to move it from Tier I to Tier III. At the February 25, 2025 Planning Commission hearing, staff recommended denial. They pointed out that the lot was on the Florida Forever acquisition list and that the Monroe County Land Authority said it could make an offer if the property were listed on the MLS.
The Navy's representative placed the parcel inside the MIAI at 55 to 64 DNL. That is below the 65 dB line that splits the island. The Navy recommended noise-reducing construction and notice to future occupants. After the state granted the owner's request on August 8, 2025, to remove the lot from the Florida Forever list, the Planning Commission approved a recommendation for the Tier III change on August 27, 2025. The Navy again asked that MIAI requirements apply to future uses.
Put the two cases side by side. On Avenue A, a lot below 65 DNL drew Navy recommendations and moved forward. At 8 Parrot Lane, a lot on the APZ boundary at 70 to 75 dB drew a formal objection and was postponed. Both are in the MIAI, and both are near Boca Chica Field.
The Navy describes accident potential zones as land use planning tools. They show where a mishap would be more likely if one occurred. They don't predict whether one will.
At the same May 2026 meeting, Planning Commission Chair Demes said that over the prior year the Navy had sharply increased its efforts to protect the properties it buys through land acquisition, both against encroachment and for endangered and protected species habitat. The county plan adds a related step. When an owner asks for more density in an incompatibility zone, the policy tells the county to encourage the Navy to acquire the land.
Public agencies have a stake in land around Boca Chica. The Land Authority showed interest in a Johnsonville lot, and the Navy is guarding the land it owns while pushing back on more intense use near the runways.
Annual averages smooth out how the airfield actually sounds. The Navy's FAQ says night training is part of the mission. Field Carrier Landing Practice runs later in summer, when sunset comes after 8:30 p.m., and it can pick up before carrier deployments. Night vision goggle training needs moonlight, so pilots "chase the moon" between moonrise and moonset.
Visiting squadrons add their own peaks. In February 2025, the 33rd Fighter Wing's Operation Southern Edge brought 14 F-35A aircraft and more than 300 personnel to NAS Key West. The 58th and 60th Fighter Squadrons logged more than 200 sorties and nearly 400 flight hours. In an earlier carrier-landing surge, KeysNews reported that 16 EA-18G Growlers from Electronic Attack Squadron 129 flew practice landings during Boca Chica Field's regular 7 a.m. to 10 p.m. hours, with later instrument approach training typically on Tuesdays and Thursdays.
A Saturday showing in a quiet week tells you little about what a Tuesday night in an exercise month sounds like. If you can, visit on a weeknight.
In September 2026, the Marathon & Lower Keys Association of REALTORS® reported 21 single-family closings, a $1,330,000 median sale price, 178 active listings and a 110-day median time to sale. Those figures cover association-member activity, not a defined geographic area, so they set the pace of the market rather than a Big Coppitt price.
Before you offer on Big Coppitt or Geiger Key land or a teardown, find out:
This post is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Confirm how these rules apply to a specific property with an attorney, surveyor or county planning staff.
Is all of Big Coppitt inside a high-noise zone? No. The 2018 AICUZ projects the 65 dB DNL contour over the southern half of the island. A lot on Avenue A was placed at 55 to 64 DNL.
Is there a newer Navy noise study than 2018? The Navy's NAS Key West AICUZ page still points to the 2018 study, which received final approval on June 18, 2018.
If you're looking at a Big Coppitt or Geiger Key parcel, Bobby Coe can help. Schedule a private consultation.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.