Sunlit wood-and-glass pool pavilion with limestone paving, turquoise water and a silver fan palm in a raised stone planter.

On Summerland Key, the Permit Line Prices the Lot

October 29, 2026

At the Monroe County Planning Commission on August 26, 2026, the sixth and seventh applicants in the Lower Keys market-rate building permit queue had the same score. Under the county's tie rule, the earlier application took the sixth slot. The seventh slot went to an administrative-relief award the County Commission had already approved for a Cudjoe Key property, which left the seventh-ranked applicant just outside that round.

That applicant's next chance will be slow in coming. Devin Tolpin, Senior Director of Planning and Environmental Resources, told commissioners she expects the next allocation period to open July 13, 2027, and the next awards to come around February 2028, provided the county's amendment timeline holds.

Lower Keys building rights are now rationed more tightly than the land they sit on, and that is what drives a lot's value.

Twenty-Eight a Year, Then a Pause

Monroe County's Rate of Growth Ordinance, known locally as ROGO, rations new residential building permits across unincorporated Monroe County. Allocations are split by subarea: Upper Keys, Lower Keys, and Big Pine/No Name Key. Summerland Key isn't in the Big Pine/No Name subarea, so it competes in the Lower Keys line along with Cudjoe Key.

In ROGO Year 34, which ended with the quarter that closed July 13, 2026, the Lower Keys had 28 market-rate allocations, or seven per quarter, according to the staff report figures read into the record at the August 26, 2026 Planning Commission meeting. That pace has now stopped. The calendar since spring looks like this:

  1. June 12, 2026. Last day to submit a building permit application and still compete in the final quarter of the current pool. All reviews also had to be finished before July 13.
  2. July 13, 2026. That quarter closed.
  3. August 26, 2026. The Planning Commission awarded Lower Keys market-rate allocations to applicants ranked 1 through 6, plus one administrative-relief award.
  4. July 13, 2027. The next allocation period is expected to open. The draft would change the schedule from quarterly to every six months.
  5. February 2028. The next round of awards is expected.

The Proposed Pool Splits the Line by Who Owns the Lot

Allocations will resume because of state action. Senate Bill 180 raised the Keys' hurricane evacuation time standard from 24 to 24.5 hours and added 900 permit allocations. They are distributed by each jurisdiction's count of vacant buildable lots, with priority for owner-occupied, affordable and workforce housing. Monroe County received 657 of the 900. The state's Administration Commission staged them in tranches over ten years: 219 starting January 2026, then 109.5 for the county every two years.

The draft that county staff presented at the April 22, 2026 Planning Commission meeting would create a new category, market-rate workforce. It would cover owners who earn at least 70 percent of their income as members of the Monroe County workforce, and the home would carry a 99-year deed restriction. Here is how that draft would divide the Lower Keys:

Lower Keys subarea Market-rate allocations Market-rate workforce allocations
ROGO Year 34, old pool 28, or 7 per quarter Category did not exist
First year of new framework, as proposed 10 96
Each later year, as proposed 4 20 in odd years, 19 in even years

That split could move lot prices. The same canal parcel can be worth different amounts to different buyers.

The draft would also let the County Commission reserve some or all market-rate workforce allocations for county-sponsored programs, or hold them for later distribution.

The State Is Still Reviewing the Draft

None of these numbers are final. According to the Key West Citizen, Florida's Department of Commerce objected to the amendments the County Commission approved in July. The state said they don't reserve enough new allocations for affordable housing and don't justify allowing existing early-evacuation units in coastal velocity zones.

The Citizen reported that county planning staff planned to recommend keeping the ban on affordable housing in V-zones and setting aside 5 percent of the 657, or 33 allocations, as deed-restricted affordable units. Those would add to 214 affordable workforce early-evacuation allocations already slated for distribution in October. Staff asked commissioners for direction at their October 21 meeting in Marathon and recommended continuing the item to November 17 for adoption.

The same October 21 agenda included the 2026 U.S. 1 Arterial Travel Time and Delay Study. If median speeds on the highway fall below 45 mph, development restrictions can be imposed. So the permit supply depends on more than one county vote. It also depends on state review and on how fast traffic moves on the Overseas Highway.

Administrative Relief and the Queue

At the August hearing, Assistant County Attorney Peter Morris described administrative relief as a remedy meant to head off an inverse condemnation, or takings, claim.

Relief awards also take slots from the regular line. Tolpin said granting administrative-relief allocations out of the regular quarterly pool has been County Commission practice for close to ten years. County code limits relief awards to 50 percent of a subarea's allocations per quarter. If the Lower Keys receives only four market-rate allocations a year, one relief award would take a large share of the line.

Questions That Set a Summerland Lot's Price

You can't tell what a vacant lot is worth from its acreage or canal frontage until you have answers to these:

  • Does the lot already have an allocation or an issued permit? If not, is it in the queue now, and what is its controlling date? A lot that filed before the June 12, 2026 cutoff and rolled over is in a very different position from one that has never applied.
  • How does the application score? Staff proposed no major changes to the point system. In August, points alone didn't separate two applicants, and filing order decided it.

These rules affect real money, but this post is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Confirm your own lot's status and options with a land-use attorney or the Monroe County Planning and Environmental Resources Department before you sign anything.

Are the Four-per-Year Lower Keys Numbers Final?

No. They come from the draft framework, which the state has objected to. County staff recommended continuing adoption to November 17, 2026.

For a private consultation on a Lower Keys lot, contact Bobby Coe.

Work With Us