Cappuccino and a croissant on a teak cafe table in a sunlit tropical courtyard with palms and sea grape foliage.

Cudjoe Key's Square Grouper Block, From Morning Coffee to the Raw Bar Upstairs

November 19, 2026

"All the things I can't do downstairs at Square Grouper, I can do upstairs at My New Joint," Lynn Bell told Keys Weekly in the spring of 2015, a month after the lounge above her restaurant opened. "I can have a happy hour, live music, late night hours and a raw bar."

The same idea has shaped the stretch of Overseas Highway around Square Grouper on Cudjoe Key since 2015. Each business that opened near the restaurant took an hour Square Grouper leaves empty: early morning, the afternoon gap between lunch and dinner, and late night. The restaurant has since opened in Islamorada and Key West, and the Cudjoe original is still the only one with a full day built around it.

The Original Is the One Lynn Bell Still Runs

Square Grouper Bar & Grill sits at MM 22.5 oceanside. The name is old Keys slang. According to Keys Weekly, fishermen and smugglers called the bales of marijuana they found floating offshore "square grouper," and all three locations decorate with burlap-wrapped bales and photos of real smugglers. In 2023 the paper called the restaurant Bell's "popular mainstay" for the past 20 years.

The family took it up the Keys first. On March 1, 2019, Bell opened a second Square Grouper in an old boathouse at the Islamorada Marina, with her son Joe and daughter Sarah. Both had worked at the Cudjoe restaurant since they were children. Joe was general manager in Islamorada, and he told Keys Weekly that his job was keeping it close to the original: "If a guest goes down to Cudjoe and is coming to have dinner here, making sure, for instance, that the seafood stew tastes the same is important."

The third location opened at 920 Caroline St. in Key West, the building longtime locals remember as PT's Late Night and later as Off the Hook. When Keys Weekly reviewed it in April 2025, Joe Bell ran Key West, and Lynn Bell still owned and operated Cudjoe while spending a few days a week in town. The Key West restaurant has a raw bar, weekend brunch dishes and cornhole and ping-pong outside. It has no coffee shop next door, no provisions store and no ice cream trailer. Those sit beside the Cudjoe original.

Before Lunch: Morning Joint and the Building Next Door

The first hour of the day belongs to Morning Joint at 22864 Overseas Hwy. Bell bought the building, and Austin and Miranda Gagnon own and operate the café. It opened on Jan. 23, 2023, with Bell's backing, as Keys Weekly reported that February. The coffee is Colombian, from a farm owned by a friend of the couple, and the waffles drew the most attention at the opening. One version came topped with fresh whipped cream and Fruity Pebbles.

Austin Gagnon explained the reason for the café in the same article: "there really is no place in this neighborhood for people to gather, hold a small meeting, or just relax and hang out." Behind the building is a back patio with tables and swings hung from the trees, open to kids and dogs. The café's site, updated in October 2026, says it is open daily for breakfast and lunch until 4:20 p.m., serves the full breakfast menu until 3 p.m. and takes call-ahead takeout orders. The site also says local musicians play on weekends during the season.

Mary Jane's Closet shares the building and connects to the café inside. Bell opened it in December 2022, two weeks before Christmas. She told Keys Weekly she wanted it ready for the holidays. At the opening it sold Vermont cheddar, wine by the bottle and glass, and charcuterie you could eat there, take home or pack for a day on the boat. The shop's site now lists glassware, ceramics and jewelry from Keys artisans, Keys publications, fishing shirts and Square Grouper and My New Joint hats. It says the shop is open daily from 8 a.m. to 4:20 p.m. For anyone shopping for gifts this season, it sells local art and ceramics a short drive from home.

Lunch and Dinner Downstairs

Square Grouper's own schedule explains why the other businesses fill the hours they do. The restaurant's website lists service Tuesday through Saturday, with lunch from 11 a.m. to 2:30 p.m. and dinner from 5 to 10 p.m. That leaves Sunday and Monday dark downstairs, plus a two-and-a-half-hour gap between lunch and dinner on the days it is open. Calling ahead before a weekday lunch saves a wasted trip.

The restaurant describes its focus as fresh, local seafood, and says its paper products and straws are made from corn. Gift certificates are sold through its online store, which matters once holiday shopping starts.

The Afternoon Gap: Icestream

The hours between lunch and dinner went to the newest piece. In November 2024, Keys Weekly reported that Austin Gagnon had opened Icestream at Morning Joint, a homemade ice cream shop in a renovated Airstream trailer beside the café. Staff member Rachel Moloney made the small-batch ice cream each week with a deep freezer on the property. Flavors changed weekly, and recent ones included sea-salted munchies, strawberry cheesecake, peanut butter and jelly, and sweet corn.

At the time of that report, Icestream was open from 2 to 9 p.m. and closed on Tuesdays. Those hours start a half hour before Square Grouper stops serving lunch and run past the café's 4:20 close, so someone was serving on the property all afternoon. Gagnon told the paper that he and his wife had "really put a lot of work into our outside area to make it a community space that is super kid- and pet-friendly," and that farmers markets were coming. Morning Joint's homepage still links to Icestream's site.

4:20 and Later: Upstairs at My New Joint

The upstairs lounge was the first piece Bell added, and she built it for the hours the restaurant doesn't serve. My New Joint describes itself as a cocktail lounge, tapas bar and live-music venue with a raw bar, oysters, cocktails, beer and wine.

When it opened in 2015, the bar started serving at 4:20 p.m. every day. The cocktails were named after cannabis strains, and the frozen drink machine was called Mary Jane's Frozen Addiction. The 4,200-square-foot room was built around a glass-front walk-in cooler holding wine and 170 bottled craft beers, with 15 beers on draft. The menu was built for sharing, with fondue, sliders, platters of shrimp or oysters and mini gingerbread donuts. Many dishes were priced "for two."

Bell explained the late hours to Keys Weekly that spring: "I think plenty of people in the Lower and Middle Keys like the idea of stopping for one last drink and a bite, or dessert, on their way home. Plus, our late night hours are popular with the service industry. They can come in after work." The lounge's phone number in that 2015 story was 305-745-8880, and a quick call before a late visit confirms this season's hours.

Two Cudjoe Kitchens Off the Block

The Square Grouper block covers a full day, but two other Cudjoe kitchens are close by. A few doors away at 22836 Overseas Hwy, Morita's Cuban Cafe makes Cuban sandwiches, picadillo, sweet plantains and café con leche. Visit Florida Keys lists its usual hours as 9 a.m. to 3 p.m., closed Sundays.

Off the highway at 21611 Old State Road 4A, Broil cooks steak in a region known for seafood. A Florida Keys Free Press feature described the restaurant as co-owned by father and daughter Brad and Lola Weiss. Brad spent 30 years managing CC's City Broiler, a steakhouse in Columbia, Missouri. He was recruited to Broil when it opened in early 2021 and bought it from founder Scott Cleeton two weeks later. The beef comes from Nebraska and Kansas and is cut in-house. Head chef JR Hanson cooks every entree over a red oak wood fire, and the Free Press named the Dijon-rubbed Beef Wellington as the likely signature dish.

According to the Free Press, Broil took reservations only for Christmas Eve, New Year's Eve and Valentine's Day, and the feature listed dinner from 5 to 9 p.m., Wednesday through Sunday. If you want a holiday table this year, call the restaurant at 305-741-7879 to confirm current hours and how those nights book. With Broil on Sundays and Morita's at lunch, Cudjoe has a choice on both Square Grouper's closed days and the hours between its meals.

If you're weighing a house on Cudjoe Key, the drive to coffee and dinner is one factor, and the canal and the community it sits in are others. Our guide to how Cudjoe Key's three distinct markets price differently covers those. When you're ready to see the island in person, Bobby Coe can plan the tour around lunch at MM 22.5. Schedule a private consultation.

Work With Us